The recent incident at the Rotary Club of St Johns has sparked controversy and raised important questions about the appropriate way to conduct debates and discussions, particularly in relation to sensitive issues such as race and ethnicity.
At the center of the incident was a toilet seat trophy, adorned with a caricature mask of former Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern, which was awarded to the team that argued that Robert Muldoon was a better prime minister. While some may argue that the debate topic and costumes were meant to be harmless fun, others have criticized them as insensitive and disrespectful, particularly in light of the ongoing discussions and debates around issues of racism, cultural sensitivity, and respect for diversity.
It is important to recognize the contrast between Ardern and Muldoon, and the impact of their respective actions on communities of color. Ardern’s “ifoga” ceremony in 2019, where she apologized to Pacific Island communities for the government’s role in the “dawn raids” of the 1970s, was a powerful demonstration of empathy, respect, and the recognition of historical wrongs. In contrast, Muldoon’s implementation of the dawn raids was a discriminatory policy that had a lasting impact on many Pacific Islanders living in New Zealand.
The incident at the Rotary Club of St Johns highlights the need for greater sensitivity and respect in our discussions and debates, particularly when it comes to issues of race and ethnicity. It is important to ensure that such discussions are conducted in a respectful and constructive manner that does not denigrate or disrespect individuals or groups based on their ethnicity or cultural background.
As a society, we need to confront and acknowledge our biases and prejudices, and work towards building a more inclusive and respectful society that values diversity and promotes understanding and cooperation among all members of our community. This includes being open to new ideas and perspectives, being willing to listen and learn from others, and treating others with kindness, respect, and empathy.
The incident at the Rotary Club of St Johns serves as a reminder of the importance of approaching discussions and debates with sensitivity, respect, and an open mind. By doing so, we can work towards building a more just and equitable society that values diversity and promotes understanding and cooperation among all members of our community.
